I am often asked which is better. Learning guitar with a qualified instructor or learing at one’s own pace using books and online resources.
The simple quick (and perhaps cop-out) answer is both.
But you probably aren’t looking for a simple answer so I will discuss the pros and cons of each.
Private Lessons:
The most obvious benefit is that there is someone who can give you immediate feedback and demonstrate each concept for you unitl you are comfortable.
A qualified instructor also has many of the concepts you will need to learn ingrained through experience.
You may not have a clear course in your mind and this is where the instructor in invaluable. Often the student wants to just jam and play songs without learning the underlying principles.
Learning on your own:
Learning on your own has many benefits as well.
The most important is that you will have a much better chance on internalizing what you learn. What I mean is that you will “own” the material you learn on a much deeper level than if you were spoon fed the concepts.
You will be able to learn at your own pace and choose exactly what you want to learn which will keep you motivated.
The internet offers many resources for learning. Tab sites, memberships sites, Ebooks and videos and DVDs.
Forums are also a very good resource for learning and sharing your experiences. Chances are there is someone who is trying to learn or at the same level and same interests as you.
A great way you learn on your own is by DVDs. Guitar Lesson DVDs show you the correct fingering and you can refer to them over and over. Often times you can get the equivalent of 5-10 lessons which brings me to the biggest advantage on learning on your own and that is cost. Private lessons run from 30-60 per hour or more. For many this is just too much. The internet offers lots of Free information and low cost information.
One critical decision you need to make is how do you best learn. Some learn best with books, some by being show what to do. Some just listen and try to copy. I personally advocate all of these and here is why. Learning fro books can show you the notes to play but not very often the form to use. Being shown how to play something can be very effective but you don’t get a chance to work on your hearing skills. So I think a great way to proceed is try to copy something by listening, then if you get stuck use another resource such as a book or video and then find a professional who can validate you are performing the piece correctly.
I hope this gives some clarity to this question and I invite your comments.